叶素芬;张珞平;陈伟琪;

• 1:厦门大学海洋与海岸带发展研究院

摘要(Abstract)：

近年来,随着我国核电事业迅猛发展,海洋放射性污染的风险激增,放射物质的事故性污染将成为海洋环境一个重要问题。目前,海洋环境放射性污染风险评估的研究仍然较为薄弱,开展海洋放射性污染生态风险评价有助于了解事故对海洋生态的危害程度,为海洋与海岸带环境管理提供科学决策依据,维护海洋生态系统的健康与安全。梳理总结当前国内外海洋放射性污染生态风险评价的相关研究进展,结果表明:目前国内外对海洋放射性污染生态风险评价尚未做出科学的定义;现有海洋放射性污染生态风险评价的技术路线大体可归纳为基于经典风险评估框架和基于迭代的生态风险评价框架2种类型;ERICA Tool模型以及RESRAD-BIOTA模型是目前放射性风险评价中应用最多的方法 ,但存在海洋放射性污染标准限值少的问题;现有的研究主要集中于评估事故中后期均衡条件下的长期慢性暴露评价,对事故初期的高剂量、短期急性暴露的风险影响研究较少;我国海洋放射性污染的生态风险评价与环境影响评价的概念混淆,至今没有明确的海洋放射性污染生态风险评价的概念及技术框架。

关键词(KeyWords)： 海洋放射性污染;生态风险评价;研究进展

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家海洋局南海环境监测中心和福建省海洋环境与渔业资源监测中心委托项目

作者(Author): 叶素芬;张珞平;陈伟琪;

Email:

参考文献(References)：

• [1]Zinger-Gize I,Larsson C M,Jones C.The Application of An Ecological Risk Assessment Approach to Define Environmental Impact of Ionizing Radiation[M]//P rotection of the Environment from Ionising Radiation.2003:142
• [2]Institut de Radioprotection et de SretéNucléaire(IRSN).Fukushima,one year later initial analyses of the accident and its consequences.Report IRSN/DG/2012-003.[R].IRSN,2012.http://www.irsn.fr/EN/publications/technical-publications/Documents/IRSN_Fukushima-1-year-later_2012-003.pdf
• [3]陈立奇,何建华,林武辉,等.海洋核污染的应急监测与评估技术展望[J].中国工程科学,2011,13(10):34-39
• [4]国家发展和改革委员会.核电中长期发展规划(2005-2020年)[OL].(2007-11-04)[2015-12-09].http://www.chinanews.com/gn/news/2007/11-04/1067944.shtml
• [5]张玉敏,李红,朱春来,等.海洋核污染与放射性监测技术[J].舰船科学技术,2010,32(12):76-79Zhang Y M,Li H,Zhu C L,et al.Nuclear contamination and radiation monitoring of the ocean[J].Ship Science and Technology,2010,32(12):76-79(in Chinese)
• [6]谭大刚.环境核辐射污染及防治对策[J].沈阳师范学院学报:自然科学版,1999(1):68-73Tan D G.Discussion on the environmental pollution of radioactive nuclides and its prevention[J].Journal of Shenyang Normal University:Natural Science,1999(1):68-73(in Chinese)
• [7]唐森铭,商照荣.近海辐射环境与生物多样性保护[J].核安全,2009(2):1-10Tang S M,Shang Z R.Coastal sea radiation environment and biodiversity protection[J].Nuclear Safety,2009(2):1-10(in Chinese)
• [8]何祚庥.中国有可能也会爆发一次重大核事故吗[OL].(2012-07-02)[2015-12-09].http://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-43021-588044.html
• [9]Hunt G J.Radiological Assessment of Ocean Radioactivity[M]//Livingston H D.Marine Radioactivity.Elsevier Ltd.,2005:205-236
• [10]United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation(UNSCEAR).Effects of radiation on the environment.Report to the General Assembly,Annex 1,United Nations[R].New York:UNSCEAR,1996
• [11]US Department of Energy.Radiation Protection of the P ublic and the Environment.DOE Order 5400.5.[R].Washington DC,USA:US Department of Energy,1993
• [12]US Department of Energy.Radiation Protection of the P ublic and the Environment[R].Washington DC,USA:US Department of Energy,1996
• [13]International Atomic Energy Agency(IAEA).Analytical techniques in uranium exploration and ore processing.Technical Report Series No.341.[R].Vienna:IAEA,1992
• [14]US Department of Energy.Establishment of biota dose assessment committee and invitation for membership.Memorandum from A.Wallo III[R].Washington DC:US Department of Energy,1998
• [15]Sazykina T G,Kryshev I I.Estimation of the control concentration of radionuclides in sea water considering health physics and radioecological criteria[J].Atomic Energy,1999,87:302-307
• [16]中华人民共和国国家环境保护总局.GB3097-1997中华人民共和国国家标准海水水质标准[S].北京:技术标准出版社出版,1997
• [17]张晓峰,上官志洪,赵锋.阳江核电厂附近海域生物辐射影响评价研究[J].热带海洋学报,2009(6):35-40Zhang X F,Shangguan Z H,Zhao F.Assessment of radiological impact on the marine organisms near Yangjiang Nuclear P ower P lant[J].Journal of Tropical Oceanography,2009(6):35-40(in Chinese)
• [18]International Atomic Energy Agency(IAEA).The radiological accident in Goinia.STI/P UB/815.[R].Vienna,Austria:IAEA,1988:132
• [19]US Department of Energy.A Graded Approach for Evaluating Radiation Doses to Aquatic and Terrestrial Biota[M].Washington DC:US Department of Energy,2002
• [20]Brechignac F.Protection of the environment:How to position radioprotection in an ecological risk assessment perspective[J].Science of the Total Environment,2003,307(1):35-54
• [21]张晓峰,陶云良,上官志洪.水生生物辐射剂量率计算在核电厂环境影响评价中的应用[J].环境保护科学,2008,34(2):117-120Zhang X F,Tao Y L,Shangguan Z H.The application of radiation dose rate calculation to aquatic organisms in EIA for nuclear power plant[J].Environmental P rotection Science,2008,34(2):117-120(in Chinese)
• [22]Bird G A,Thompson P A,Macdonald C R,et al.Assessment of the impact of radionuclide releases from Canadian nuclear facilities on non-human biota[C].Third International Symposium on P rotection of the Environment from Ionizing Radiation(SP EIR 3).Vienna,Austria:International Atomic Energy Agency,2003:241-247
• [23]Wilson R C,i Batlle J V,Watts S J,et al.An approach for the assessment of risk from chronic radiation to populations of phytoplankton and zooplankton[J].Radiation and Environmental Biophysics,2010,49(1):87-95
• [24]Robinson C A.Development of An International Framework for the P rotection of the Environment from the Effects of Ionizing Radiation[M]//P rotection of the Environment from Ionising Radiation.2003:110
• [25]陈妍,郑鹏,陈海英,等.核电厂环境风险评价框架及方法[J].科技导报,2015,33(4):37-43Chen Y,Zheng P,Chen H Y,et al.Framework and approach for environmental risk assessment of nuclear power plants[J].Science&Technology Review,2015,33(4):37-43(in Chinese)
• [26]Larsson C M.The FASSET framework for assessment of environmental impact of ionising radiation in European ecosystems—An overview[J].Journal of Radiological P rotection,2004,24(4A):A1-A12
• [27]Zinger I,Larsson C M,Beresford N A,et al.Environmental risk from ionising contaminants:Assessment and management.P eriodic Activity report(P ar-No:1)Reporting period:EG 01/03/04-28/02/06[R].Brussels:European Commission,2006
• [28]马丽,王建华,李吉鹏,等.某滨海核电厂低放射性废水的海洋环境影响预评价[J].应用海洋学学报,2013(1):29-35Ma L,Wang J H,Li J P,et al.Marine environmental impact pre-assessment for low-level radioactive waste water from a coastal nuclear power plant[J].Journal of Applied Oceanography,2013(1):29-35(in Chinese)
• [29]韩宝华.评价电离辐射对环境危害的方法——欧洲ERICA项目简介[J].辐射防护通讯,2010,30(5):6-12Han B H.Approach to assessment of environmental risks from ionizing radiation:An overview of the ERICA P roject[J].Radiation P rotection Bulletin,2010,30(5):6-12(in Chinese)
• [30]US Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Severe accident risks:An assessment for five US nuclear power plants NUREG-1150[R].Washington DC:US Nuclear Regulatory Commission,1990
• [31]US EPA.Framework for Ecological Risk Assessment.EP A/630/R-92/001[C].Risk Assessment Forum,Washington DC:Office of Research and Development,1992
• [32]US EPA.Guidelines for Carcinogen Risk Assessment.FRL3201122[R].Washington DC:US EP A,1998
• [33]Mathews T,Beaugelin-Seiller K,Garnier-Laplace J,etal.A probabilistic assessment of the chemical and radiological risks of chronic exposure to uranium in freshwater ecosystems[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2009,43(17):6684-6690
• [34]World Health Organization.WHO Report on Integrated Risk Assessment.WHO/IP CA/RA/01/12[R].Geneva,Switzerland:WHO,2001
• [35]Friant S L,Brandt C A.Ecological Risk Assessment of Radionuclides in the Columbia River System—A Historical Assessment[M]//A Review of Ecological Assessment Case Studies from a Risk Assessment P erspective,vol II,EP A/630/R-94/003.Washington DC:US Environmental P rotection Agency,1994
• [36]Copplestone D,Bielby S,Jones S R,et al.Impact assessment of ionising radiation on wildlife[R].Bristol,UK:Environment Agency,2001
• [37]Brown J E,Hosseini A,Brretzen P,et al.Development of a methodology for assessing the environmental impact of radioactivity in Northern Marine environments[J].Marine Pollution Bulletin,2006,52(10):1127-1137
• [38]郑伟,白晓平.液态放射性流出物对水生生物辐射影响评价初探[J].铀矿冶,2008,27(3):134-137Zheng W,Bai X P.P reliminary study on radiological impact assessment of radioactive liquid effluent to aquatic biota[J].Mining and Metallurgy,2008,27(3):134-137(in Chinese)
• [39]白晓平.RESRAD-BIOTA程序的改进及其应用研究[J].科技导报,2009,27(12):61-64Bai X P.Modification and application of RESRAD-BIOTA P rogram[J].Science&Technology Review,2009,27(12):61-64(in Chinese)
• [40]Wood M D,Marshall W A,Beresford N A,et al.Application of the ERICA Integrated Approach to the drigg coastal sand dunes[J].Journal of Environmental Radioactivity,2008,99(9):1484-1495
• [41]Beresford N A,Barnett C L,Howard D C,et al.Screening Level Assessment of Releases from Oil and Gas P latforms on Marine Natura 2000 Sites[M]//Radioecology&Environmental Radioactivity-Environment&Nuclear Renaissance.Hamilton,Ontario,Canada:Mc Master University,2011
• [42]Sin H S,Sarmani S,Siong K K.Radiological impact assessment of Fukushima Dai-ichi Nuclear Accident on Malaysian marine biotas via ocean partway using Erica Code System[J].Sains Malaysiana,2014,43(10):1565-1571
• [43]i Batlle J V,Aono T,Brown J E,et al.The impact of the Fukushima nuclear accident on marine biota:Retrospective assessment of the first year and perspectives[J].Science of the Total Environment,2014,487:143-153
• [44]傅小城,王茹静,杜风雷.内陆核电非人类物种辐射影响评价研究——AP1000机型初步评价[J].辐射防护通讯,2014(1):1-7Fu X C,Wang R J,Du F L.Assessment of radiological impact on non-human biota near in-land NP P—P rimary assessment of AP 1000[J].Radiation P rotection Bulletin,2014(1):1-7(in Chinese)
• [45]Aliyu A S,Ramli A T,Garba N N,et al.Fukushima nuclear accident:P reliminary assessment of the risks to non-human biota[J].Radiation P rotection Dosimetry,2015,163(2):238-250
• [46]Yu W,He J,Lin W,et al.Distribution and risk assessment of radionuclides released by Fukushima nuclear accident at the northwest P acific[J].Journal of Environmental Radioactivity,2015,142:54-61
• [47]Shen J,Biglari M,Jiang C B,et al.A transfer pathway modeling template for radiological environmental risk assessment[J].Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment,2010,24(8):1089-1096
• [48]张春粦,许自图,肖璋.大亚湾核电站低放废水排放对附近水域环境影响的研究[J].核动力工程,1987,8(3):54-64Zhang C L,Xu Z T,Xiao Z.The research on the environmental impact on nearby waters range at low-level radioactive waste water drain from the Dayawan Nuclear P ower Station[J].Nuclear P ower Engineering,1987,8(3):54-64(in Chinese)
• [49]Corrigall R.Generic models for use in assessing the impact of discharges of radioactive substances to the environment[J].The British Journal of Radiology,2004,77(916):365
• [50]苏柯.大亚湾核电液态排放的潮流污染扩散及海洋生态转移研究[D].广州:暨南大学,2005:8-9Su K.The research on the law of tide induced dispersion of the liquid radioactive wastes of Daya Bay nuclear power station and on the law of radionuclide transfer in the marine ecosystem[D].Guangzhou:Jinan University,2005:8-9(in Chinese)
• [51]苏柯.海洋生态系统中放射性核素转移的数值模拟[J].海洋科学,2007,31(10):51-54Su K.The numerical simulation for the transfer of the radionuclide from the liquid releases of the nuclear power station to the ocean systems in the ecosystems[J].Marine Sciences,2007,31(10):51-54(in Chinese)
• [52]Margvelashvily N,Maderich V,Zheleznyak M.Simulation of radionuclide fluxes from the Dnieper-Bug Estuary into the Black Sea[J].Journal of Environmental Radio-activity,1999,43(2):157-171
• [53]Margvelashvili N,Maderich V,Yuschenko S,et al.3-D numerical modeling of mud and radionuclide transport in the Chernobyl Cooling P ond and Dnieper-Boog Estuary[J].Proceedings in Marine Science,2002,5:595-609
• [54]孔令丰.大亚湾放射生态学及海洋生物转移与卷载效应的研究[D].广州:暨南大学,2007:11-66Kong L F.Research on radioecology at Daya Bay–A study on the transfer of radionuclide in the marine ecosystem and entrainment effect of marine organism[D].Guangzhou:Jinan University,2007:11-66(in Chinese)
• [55]乔清党,郭猜,杨静,等.海域放射性后果评价方法研究[J].核安全,2015,14(2):12-19Qiao Q D,Guo C,Yang J,et al.Method research of radiation consequence evaluation in the ocean discharged from nuclear accident[J].Nuclear Safety,2015,14(2):12-19(in Chinese)
• [56]乔方利,王关锁,赵伟,等.2011年3月日本福岛核泄漏物质输运扩散路径的情景模拟和预测[J].科学通报(中文版),2011,56(12):887-894Qiao F L,Wang G S,Zhao W,et al.P redicting the spread of nuclear radiation from the damaged Fukushima Nuclear P ower P lant[J].Chinese Science Bulletin,2011,56(12):887-894(in Chinese)
• [57]Tsumune D,Tsubono T,Aoyama M,et al.Distribution of oceanic 137Cs from the Fukushima Dai-ichi Nuclear P ower P lant simulated numerically by a regional ocean model[J].Journal of Environmental Radioactivity,2012,111:100-108
• [58]Kryshev I I,Sazykina T G.Assessment of radiation doses to aquatic organism's in the Chernobyl contaminated area[J].Journal of Environmental Radioactivity,1995,28(1):91-103
• [59]Chartier M,Despres A.Radiological impact on EC member states of routine discharges into the Mediterranean Sea[J].Radiation P rotection Dosimetry,1998,75(1-4):161-165
• [60]Wang J,Fang H,He G,et al.A model of 90Sr distribution in the sea near Daya Bay Nuclear P ower P lant in China[J].Frontiers of Environmental Science&Engineering,2014,8(6):845-853
• [61]Adam S.Radiological protection of the environment-sharing knowledge[OL].(2009-10-29)[2015-12-09].https://wiki.ceh.ac.uk/display/rpemain/Radiological+protection+of+the+environment+-+sharing+knowledge;jsessionid=48B489F786F18D25F0A11F93CA27395C
• [62]Beaugelin-Seiller K,Jasserand F,Garnier-Laplace J,et al.Modeling radiological dose in non-human species:P rinciples,computerization,and application[J].Health P hysics,2006,90(5):485-493
• [63]Beresford N A,Balonov M,Beaugelin-Seiller K,et al.An international comparison of models and approaches for the estimation of the radiological exposure of non-human biota[J].Applied Radiation and Isotopes,2008,66(11):1745-1749
• [64]苏健,曾志,余雯,等.大亚湾核电站周围海域水生生物人工放射性核素辐射剂量率的蒙特卡罗计算[J].台湾海峡,2011,30(3):301-309Su J,Zeng Z,Yu W,et al.Monte Carlo calculation of artificial radionuclide radiation doses for aquaticorganisms in the sea area around Daya Bay Nuclear P ower P lant[J].Journal of Oceanography in Taiwan Strait,2011,30(3):301-309(in Chinese)
• [65]李静晶,刘森林,毛亚蔚,等.水生生物的辐射剂量率估算方法[J].辐射防护,2010(4):236-241Li J J,Liu S L,Mao Y W,et al.A method for estimating radiation dose rates to aquatic biota[J].Radiation P rotection,2010(4):236-241(in Chinese)
• [66]李静晶,刘森林,王春红.鲻鱼解剖学模型剂量计算及与整体模型的比较[J].原子能科学技术,2011,45(2):150-155Li J J,Liu S L,Wang C H.Calculation on radiation doses to mullet in anatomic model and comparison to unitary model[J].Atomic Energy Science and Technology,2011,45(2):150-155(in Chinese)
• [67]李培泉,康兴伦.水生生物的辐射剂量率——Ⅲ.环境中水生生物的辐射剂量率[J].海洋湖沼通报,1983(2):61-73Li P Q,Kang X L.Radiation dose rates of aquatic organismsⅢ.Radiation dose of aquatic organisms from environments[J].Transactions of Oceanology and Limnology,1983(2):61-73(in Chinese)
• [68]李冰,陈莹莹,余少青,等.福岛第一核电站事故后放射性废液的泄漏/排放及辐射影响评估[J].辐射防护,2012,32(6):336-347Li B,Chen Y Y,Yu S Q,et al.P ost-accident leakage and discharge of radioactive waste liquid at Fukushima Dai-ichi NP P and its envriomental impacts[J].Radiation P rotection,2012,32(6):336-347(in Chinese)
• [69]Duffa C,Thebault H.A radioecological risk assessment tool for post-accidental situations:Application in the Toulon marine area(South of France)[J].Japanese Journal of Taste&Smell Research,2010,17:297-300
• [70]Beresford N,Brown J,Copplestone D,et al.D-ERICA:An integrated approach to the assessment and management of environmental risk from ionising radiation.De-scription of purpose,methodology and application[R].Brussels:European Commission,2007
• [71]李静晶,刘森林,陈超峰,等.使用RESRAD-BIOTA程序和ERICA程序计算某核电厂址附近水域中华鲟剂量的对比[J].辐射防护通讯,2009,29(6):6-12Li J J,Liu S L,Chen C F,et al.Comparison between calculations of dose to Chinese sturgeon by RESRAD-BIOTA P rogram and ERICA P rogram[J].Radiation P rotection Bulletin,2009,29(6):6-12(in Chinese)
• [72]白晓平,杜红燕,郑伟.RESRAD-BIOTA和ERICA程序对滨海核电厂浅水鱼的辐射剂量估算比较研究[J].辐射防护,2011,31(2):65-71Bai X P,Du H Y,Zheng W.Comparative study of RESRAD-BIOTA and ERICA P rograms in assessment of radiation effect on pelagic fish[J].Radiation P rotection,2011,31(2):65-71(in Chinese)
• [73]刘悦,曾志,赵颖,等.大亚湾周围海域几种水生生物的辐射剂量估算[J].辐射防护,2011,31(5):300-305Liu Y,Zeng Z,Zhao Y,et al.Four non-human species radiation assessment in Daya Bay[J].Radiation P rotection,2011,31(5):300-305(in Chinese)