穆景利;王莹;王菊英;

• 1:国家海洋环境监测中心
• 2:厦门大学环境科学研究中心近海海洋环境国家重点实验室

摘要(Abstract)：

我国近岸海域污染形势严峻、污染物种类繁多、生态健康风险复杂,现有的海水水质标准难以满足当前海洋环境污染评价、管理和监控的需求,亟需适宜我国海洋区系特征的海水水质基准作为水质标准修订与制定的理论依据.借鉴美国、欧盟和荷兰等国家水质基准的制定方法,提出了构建我国海水水质基准的思路,并给出了数值型双值基准的数据要求、定值方法和相应的计算模式等.以三丁基锡化合物(TBT)为例,按照论文建立的方法,计算了保护我国海洋水生生物的TBT基准.结果表明:我国TBT化合物海水水质基准高值(HSWC)和海水水质基准低值(LSWC)分别为0.43μg·L-1和0.002μg·L-1,与美国,加拿大和英国等国家的推荐基准值略有不同.研究结果将为我国海水水质基准的制定与研究提供帮助.

关键词(KeyWords)： 海洋环境;有机锡;水质基准;评价因子;物种敏感性分布

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 海洋公益性行业科研专项(No.200805090);; 国家“863”项目(No.2007AA09Z126);; 国家“908”评价专项项目(No.908-02-02-01)

作者(Author): 穆景利;王莹;王菊英;

Email:

DOI:

参考文献(References)：

• ANZECC(Australian and New Zealand Environment andConservation Council).1992.Australian Water Quality Guidelinesfor Fresh and Marine Waters[R].Canberra,Australia:Australianand New Zealand Environment and Conservation Council,ACT,.November1992
• ANZECC and ARMCANZ.2000.Australian and New ZealandGuidelines for fresh and marine water quality[R].Canberra,Australia:Australian and New Zealand Environmental andConservation Council and Agriculture and Resource MangementCouncil of Australia and New Zealand.
• Barnthouse L W.2004.Quantifying population recovery rates forecological risk assessment[J].Environmental Toxicology andChemistry,23(2):500-508
• Brooke L T,Call D J,Poirier S H,Markee T P,Lindberg CA,McCauley D J,Simonson P G.1986.Acute Toxicity andChronic Effects of Bis(tri-n-butyltin)Oxide to Several Species ofFreshwater Organisms[R].Center for Lake Superior EnvironmentalStudies,University of Wisconsin-Superior,Superior
• Bushong S J,Hall L W,Jr,Hall W S,Johnson W E,HermanR L.1988.Acute toxicity of tributyltin to selected ChesapeakeBay fish and invertebrates[J].Water Research,22(8):10271032
• Caldwell D J,Mastrocco F,Hutchinson T H,Lnge R,HeijerickD,Janssen C,Anderson P D,Sumpter J P.2008.Derivation ofan aquatic predicted no-effect concentration for the synthetichormone,17β-ethinyl estradiol[J].Environmental Science andTechnology,42(19):7046-7054
• Cao D,Jiang G,Zhou Q,Yang R.2009.Organotin pollution inChina:an overview of the current state and potential health risk[J].Journal of Environmental Management,90(Supplement1):S16-S24
• CCME.1999.A protocol for the Derivation of Water QualityGuildelines for the Protection of Aquatic Life.CanadianEnvironemental Quailty Guidelines[R].Ottawa,Canada:CanadianCouncile of Minsiters of the Environment
• Chen H M,Jin H J,Yang X.1998.Methodology of derivationof quality standards for protecting aquatic environment[J].Shanghai Environmental Sciences,17(4):10-14(in Chinese)
• Chen T J,Song Z H,Shen L S.1998.Toxic effect oftributyltin on spirulina subsalsa[J].Chinese Journal of EnvironmentalScience,19(1):87-88(in Chinese)
• Chen T J,Tan Y S,Tian M.1993.Toxic effects of organotincompounds to benthic animal[J].Chinese Journal of EnvironmentalScience,15(5):63-65(in Chinese)
• Clark J R,Patrick J M,Moore J C,Lores E M.1987.Waterborne and sediment-source toxicities of six organic chemicalsto grass shrimp(Palaemonetes pugio)and amphioxus(Branchiostomacaribaeum)[J].Archives of Environmental Contamination andToxicology,16(4):401-407
• Crisinel A,Delaunay L,Rossel D,Tarradellas J,Meyer H,Saiah H,Vogel P,Delisle C,Blaise C.1994.Cyst-based ecotoxicologicaltests using anostracans:comparison of two species of streptocephalus[J].Environmental Toxicology and Water Quality,9(4):317326
• Davies I M,McKie J C,Paul J D.1986.Accumulation of tinand tributyltin from anti-fouling paint by cultivated scallops(Pecten maximus)and Pacific oysters(Crassostrea gigas)[J].Aquaculture,55:103-114
• De Coen W M,Vangheluwe M L,Janssen C R.1998.The useof biomarkers in Daphnia magna toxicity testing.III.Rapidtoxicity testing of pure chemicals and sediment pore waters usingingestion and digestive enzyme activity[J].Chemosphere,37(13):2677-2694
• De Vries H,Penninks A H,Snoeij N J,Seinen W.1991.Comparative toxicity of organotin compounds to rainbow trout(Oncorhynchus mykiss)Yolk Sac Fry[J].Science of the TotalEnvironment,103(2-3):229-243
• ECB.2003.Technical Guidance Document on Risk Assessment inSupport of Commission Directive93/97EEC on Risk Assessmentfor New Notified Substances,Commisson Regulation(EC)no.1488/94on Risk Assessment for Existing Substances andDirective98/8/EC of the European Parlianment and of theCouncil Concenrning the Placing of Biocidal Products on theMarket.Part II.Environmental Risk Assessment[R].Ispra,Italy:European Chemicals Bureau,European Commission Joint ResearchCenter,European Communities
• Gao S D,Wu Y P,Zhao X W.1994.The physiological effectsof organotin on marine microalgae,effects of organotin onphotosynthetic pigments of two marine phytoplankton[J].Oceanologia et Limnologia Sinica,25(3):259-265(in Chinese)
• Goodman L R,Cripe G M,Moody P H,Halsell D G.1988.Acute toxicity of malathion,tetrabromobisphenol-A and tributyltinchloride to mysids(Mysidopsis bahia)of three ages[J].Bulletinof Environmental Contamination and Toxicology,41(5):746-753
• Hall L W,Bushong S J,Hall W S,Johnson W E.1988.Acute and chronic effects of tributyltin on a Chesapeake Bay copepod[J].Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry,7(1):41-46
• Harding M J C,Bailey S K,Davies I M.1996.Effects of TBTon the Reproductive Success of the Dogwhelk Nucella Lapillus[R].Aberdeen,Scotland:Napier University of Edinburgh andThe Scottish Office of Agriculture,Environment and FisheriesDepartment
• Huang G,Dai S,Sun H.1996.Toxic effects of organotinspecies on algae[J].Applied Organometallic Chemistry,10(5):377-387
• Jiang G B,Liu J Y,Zhou Q F.2000.Preliminary studies onthe occurrence of organotins in Chinese inland water system[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,20(5):636-638(in Chinese)
• Jin X W,Lei B L,Xu Y P,Cha J M,Wang Z J.2009.Methodologies forderiving water quality criteria to protect aquaticlife(ALC)and proposal for development of ALC in China:Areview[J].Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology,4(5):609-616(inChinese)
• Kusk K O,Petersen S.1997.Acute and chronic toxicity of tributyltinand linear alkylbenzene sulfonate to the marine copepod acartiatonsa[J].Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry,16(8):1629-1633
• Lapota D,Moskowitz G J,Rosenberger D E,Grovhoug J.1993The Use of Stimulable Bioluminescence from Marine Dinoflagellatesas a Means of Detecting Toxicity in the Marine Environmen[R].San Diego:Naval Command,Control and Ocean SurveillanceCenter,RDT&E Division
• Lapota D,Rosenberger D E,Duckworth D.1996.A BioluminescentDinoflagellate Assay for Detecting Toxicity in Coastal Waters[M].Bioluminescence and Chemiluminescence,Fundamentals andApplied Aspects,New York:John Wiley&Sons,156-159
• Laughlin R B.1983.Physicochemical factors influencing toxicityof organotin compounds to crab zoeae,Rhithropanopeus harrisii[J].American Zoologist,23:1004
• Lei B L,Jin X W,Huang S B,Wang Z J.2009.Discussion ofquality criteria for three chlorophenols in taihu lake[J].AsianJournal of Ecotoxicology,4(1):40-49(in Chinese)
• Lepper P.2005.Manual on the methodological framework toderive environmental quality standards for priority substances inaccordance with Article16of the Water Framework Directive(2000/60/EC)[R].Schmallenberg(DE):Fraunhofer-InstituteMolecular Biology and Applied Ecology
• Martin R C,Dixon D G,Maguire R J,Hodson P J,Tkacz R J.1989.Acute toxicity,uptake,depuration and tissue distribution oftri-n-butyltin in rainbow trout,Salmo gardneri[J].AquaticToxicology,15:37-52
• Maruyama T,Sun D,Hashimoto S,Miura A.1991.Toxiceffects of triorganotins on the adhesion and germination-growth of conchospores of Porphyra yezoensis,red arga[J].MarinePollution Bulletin,23:729-731
• Meador J P.1997.Comparative toxicokinetics of tributyltin infive marine species and its utility in predicting bioaccumulationand acute toxicity[J].Aquatic Toxicology,37(4):307-326
• Newman M C,Ownby D R,Mezin L C A,Powell D C,Cheristensen T R L.2000.Applying species sensitivity distributionin ecological risk assessment:Assumptions of distribution typeand sufficient numbers of species[J].Environmental Toxicologyand Chemistry,19(2):508-515
• OECD.1992.Fish Acute Toxicity Test(TG203).in:OECDGuideline for Testing of Chemicals[S].Paris:Organisation forEconomic Cooperation and Development
• OECD.1998.Detailed Review Paper on Aquatic Testing Methodsfor Pesticides and Industrial Chemicals.OECD Series on Testingand Assessment No.11[S].Paris:Organisation for EconomicCooperation and Development
• Posthuma L,Sutter G W,Traas T P.2002.Species SensitivityDistributions in Ecotoxicology[M].USA:Boca Raton,FL
• Ringwood A H.1992.Comparative sensitivity of gametes andearly developmental stages of a sea urchin species(Echinometramathaei)and a bivalve species(Isognomon californicum)duringmetal exposures[J].Archives of Environmental Contaminationand Toxicology,22(3):288-295
• RIVM.2001.Guidance Document on Deriving EnvironmentalRisk Limits in the Netherlands[R].601501012Bilthoven,theNetherlands:National institute of public health and the environment
• Roberts M H.1987.Acute toxicity of tributyltin chloride toembyos and larvae of two bivalve mollusks,Crassostrea virginicaand Mercenaria mercenaria[J].Bulletin of EnvironmentalContamination and Toxicology,39(6):1012-1019
• Salazar M H,Salazar S M.1989.Acute Effects of(Bis)tributyltin Oxide on Marine Organisms[R].San Diego:NavalOceans Systems Center Technical Report1299
• Song Z H,Chen T J,Liu R B.1998.Toxic effect of tributyltinon chironomus plumosus[J].Chinese Journal of EnvironmentalScience,19(2):87-91(in Chinese)
• Song Z H,Chen T J,Ma W Q.1997.Toxic effect of organotincompounds on radixplicatula[J].Chinese Journal of EnvironmentalScience,18(4):83-84(in Chinese)
• Staples C A,Woodburn K B,Klecka G M,Mihaich E M,HallA T,Ortego L,Caspers N,Hentges S G.2008.Comparison offour species sensitivity distribution methods to calculate predictedno effect concentrations for bisphenol A[J].Human and EcologicalRisk Assessment,14(3):455-478
• Stronkhorst J,Van Hattum B,Bowmer T.1999.Bioaccumulationand toxicity of tributyltin to a burrowing heart urchin and anamphipod in spiked,silty marine sediments[J].EnvironmentalToxicology&Chemistry,18(10):2343-2351
• Sun H W,Huang G L,Li S X,Dai S G,Zhang Y,Qiao F.2000.Study on toxic effects on triphenyltin and tributyltin onDaphnia magna[J].Environmental Chemistry,19(3):235-239(in Chinese)
• Tan Y,Li Y Y,Du Y B,Chen W Z,Sun Z W.2006.Acuteand chronic toxic effect of tributyltin on the guppies(poeciliareticulates)[J].Environmental Chemistry,25(3):315-319(inChinese)
• Thain J E.1983.The Acute Toxicity of Bis(tributyltin)Oxideto the Adults and Larvae of Some Marine Organisms[R].International Council for the Exploration of the Sea,MaricultureCommittee
• Tillmann M,Schulte-Oehlmann U,Duft M,Markert B,Oehlmann J.2001.Effects of endocrine disruptors on prosobranchsnails(Mollusca:Gastropoda)in the laboratory.Part III:Cyproteroneacetate and vinclozolin as antiandrogens[J].Ecotoxicology,10(6):373-388
• U.S.EPA.1985.Guidelines for Deriving Numerical NationalWater Quality Criteria for the Protection of Aquatic Organismsand Their Uses[R].PB85-227049.Washington,DC:U.S.Environmental Protection Agency
• U.S.EPA.2003.Environmental Ambient Aquatic Life WaterQuality Criteria for TBT—Final[R].Washington,DC:U.S.Environmental Protection Agency
• UKDE.1991.National Environment Quality Standards For DangerousSubstances in Water:Joint Consultation Paper[R].London:United Kingdom Department of the Environment
• Walsh G E,Louie M K,McLaughlin L L,Lorez E M.1986.Lugworm(Arenicola cristata)larvae in toxicity tests:Survivaland development when exposed to organotins[J].EnvironmentalToxicology and Chemistry,5(8):749-754
• Walsh G E,McLaughlan L L,Lores E M,Louie M K,DeansC H.1985.Effects of organotins on growth and survival of twomarine diatoms,Skeletonema costatum and Thalassiosira pseudonana[J].Chemosphere,14(3-4):383-392
• Wang S S,Feng L.2005.Toxicity of organic tin compoundsand its influencing factors[J].Journal of Safety and Environment,5(3):12-15(in Chinese)
• Xu M D,Du C M.2001.Toxic effects of organic tin onDicrateria sp[J].Journal of Oceanography of Huanghai andBohai Seas,19(1):66-69(in Chinese)
• Yan Z G,Meng W,Liu Z T,Yu R Z,Zhang Y H.2009.Biological criteria for freshwater Cd in China[J].Acta ScientiaeCircumstantiae,29(11):2393-2406(in Chinese)
• Yuan J F,Wang F,Chen X L.2001.A study on toxic effectsof TBTCl on Na+-K+-ATPase in different tissus of cyprinuscarpio Linnaeus[J].Acta Scientiarum Naturalium UniversitatisNankaiensis,34(2):104-109(in Chinese)
• Zhou Q X,Luo Y,Zhu L Y.2007.Scientific research onenvironmental benchmark values and revision of nationalenvironmental standards in China[J].Journal of Agro Environmental Science,26(1):1-5(in Chinese)
• Zhu W G,Guo R X,Yang J X.2009.Effect of endocrinedisruptors fenvalerate and TBTC on reproduction of rotiferBrachionus calyciflorus[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,29(7):36053612(in Chinese)
• 陈天乙,宋志慧,沈丽赛.1998.三丁基锡对螺旋藻的毒性作用[J].环境科学,19(1):87-88
• 陈天乙,谭元生,田明.1993.有机锡化合物对底栖动物的急性毒性研究[J].环境科学,15(5):63-65
• 程惠民,金洪钧,杨璇.1998.推导保护水生环境质量标准的方法研究[J].上海环境科学,17(4):10-14
• 高尚德,吴以平,赵心玉.1994.有机锡对海洋微藻的生理效应——三苯基锡和三丁基锡对光合色素含量的影响[J].海洋与湖沼,25(3):259-265
• 雷炳莉,金小伟,黄圣彪,王子健.2009.太湖流域3种氯酚类化合物水质基准的探讨[J].生态毒理学报,4(1):40-49
• 江桂斌,刘稷燕,周群芳.2000.我国部分内陆水域有机锡污染现状初探[J].环境科学学报,20(5):636-638
• 金小伟,雷炳莉,许宜平,查金苗,王子健.2009.水生态基准学方法概论及建立我国水生态基准的探讨[J].生态毒理学报,4(5):609-616
• 宋志慧,陈天乙,刘如冰.1998.三丁基锡对摇蚊幼虫的毒性作用[J].环境科学,19(2):87-91
• 宋志慧,陈天乙,马维琦.1997.有机锡化合物对萝卜螺的毒性作用[J].环境科学,18(4):83-84
• 孙红文,黄国兰,李叔霞,戴树桂,张悦,乔峰.2000.三苯基锡和三丁基锡对大型溞（Daphnia magna)的毒性作用研究[J].环境化学,19(3):235-239
• 谭燕,李远友,杜永兵,陈伟州,孙泽伟.2006.三丁基锡对孔雀鱼的毒性效应研究[J].环境化学,25(3):315-319
• 王珊珊,冯流.2005.有机锡化合物的毒性效应及其影响因素[J].安全与环境学报,5(3):12-15
• 徐明德,杜春梅.2001.有机锡对金藻的毒性效应[J].黄渤海海洋,19(1):66-69
• 闫振广,孟伟,刘征涛,余若祯,张亚辉.2009.我国淡水水生生物镉基准研究[J].环境科学学报,29(11):2393-2406
• 袁锦芳,王芳,陈叙龙.2001.TBTCl对鲤鱼组织N+-K+ATPase的毒性研究[J].南开大学学报,34(2):104-109
• 周启星,罗义,祝凌燕.2007.环境基准值的科学研究与我国环境标准的修订[J].农业环境科学学报,26(1):1-5
• 朱玮阁,郭瑞昕,杨家新.2009.内分泌干扰物氰戊菊酯和有机锡对萼花臂尾轮虫生殖的影响[J].生态学报,29(7):3605-3612