侯俊;赵芊渊;王超;王沛芳;苗令占;吕博文;

• 1:河海大学教育部浅水湖泊综合治理与资源开发重点实验室
• 2:河海大学环境学院

摘要(Abstract)：

运用概率物种敏感度分布法获得太湖水体中铜的急性水质基准值为14.57μg·L-1,慢性水质基准值为3.26μg·L-1;不同类别物种敏感性存在差异,无脊椎动物较脊椎动物更敏感,甲壳类敏感性大于鱼类。概率物种敏感度分布法与传统的物种敏感度分布法相比,更全面合理地考虑多种毒性效应,曲线拟合效果好,受数据量大小影响较小,结果更加稳定。研究结论可为铜水质标准的修订和太湖流域水环境管理提供技术支持。

关键词(KeyWords)： 铜;水生生物;急性毒性;慢性毒性;水质基准;太湖;概率物种敏感度分布

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家杰出青年基金项目(51225901);; 国家自然科学基金(51479047;41430751;51209069);; 国家十二五水专项课题(2012ZX07101-008);; 江苏省杰出青年基金项目(BK2012037);; 教育部创新团队发展计划(IRT13061)

作者(Author): 侯俊;赵芊渊;王超;王沛芳;苗令占;吕博文;

Email:

参考文献(References)：

• [1]吴丰昌,冯承莲,曹宇静,等.我国铜的淡水生物水质基准研究[J].生态毒理学报,2011,6(6):617-628Wu F C,Feng C L,Cao Y J,et al.Aquatic life ambient freshwater quality criteria for copper in China[J].Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology,2011,6(6):617-628(in Chinese)
• [2]冯承莲,吴丰昌,赵晓丽,等.水质基准研究与进展[J].中国科学:地球科学,2012,42(5):646-656Feng C L,Wu F C,Zhao X L,et al.Water quality criteria research and progress[J].Science China:Earth Science,2012,42(5):646-656(in Chinese)
• [3]王俊能,胡习邦,李玉炫,等.物种敏感性分布在铊污染淡水生物生态风险评估中的应用[J].安全与环境学报,2012,12(6):134-139Wang J N,Hu X B,Li Y X,et al.Assessing ecological risk of sudden thallium pollution accident to freshwater organisms by species sensitivity distributions[J].Journal of Safety and Environment,2012,12(6):134-139(in Chinese)
• [4]李玉爽,吴丰昌,崔晓勇,等.中国苯的淡水水质基准研究[J].生态学杂志,2012,31(4):908-915Li Y S,Wu F C,Cui X Y,et al.Freshwater quality criteria for benzene in China[J].Chinese Journal of Ecology,2012,31(4):908-915(in Chinese)
• [5]张瑞卿,吴丰昌,李会仙,等.应用物种敏感度分布法研究中国无机汞的水生生物水质基准[J].环境科学学报,2012,32(2):440-449Zhang R Q,Wu F C,Li H X,et al.Deriving aquatic water quality criteria for inorganic mercury in China by species sensitivity distributions[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2012,32(2):440-449(in Chinese)
• [6]Wu F C,Meng W,Zhao X L,et al.China embarking on development of its own national water quality criteria system[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2010,44(21):7992-7993
• [7]吴丰昌,孟伟,宋永会,等.中国湖泊水环境基准的研究进展[J].环境科学学报,2008,28(12):2385-2393Wu F C,Meng W,Song Y H,et al.Research progress in lake water quality criteria in China[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2008,28(12):2385-2393(in Chinese)
• [8]吴丰昌,冯承莲,曹宇静,等.锌对淡水生物的毒性特征与水质基准的研究[J].生态毒理学报,2011,6(4):367-382Wu F C,Feng C L,Cao Y J,et al.Toxicity characteristic of zinc to freshwater biota and its water quality criteria[J].Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology,2011,6(4):367-382(in Chinese)
• [9]吴丰昌,冯承莲,张瑞卿,等.我国典型污染物水质基准研究[J].中国科学:地球科学,2012,42(5):665-672Wu F C,Feng C L,Zhang R Q,et al.Derivation of water quality criteria for representative water-body pollutants in China[J].Science China:Earth Science,2012,42(5):665-672(in Chinese)
• [10]Feng C L,Wu F C,Zheng B H,et al.Biotic ligand models for metals-A practical application in the revision of water quality standards in China[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2012,46(20):10877-10878
• [11]秦延文,张雷,郑丙辉,等.太湖表层沉积物重金属赋存形态分析及污染特征[J].环境科学,2012,33(12):4291-4299Qin Y W,Zhang L,Zheng B H,et al.Speciation and pollution characteristics of heavy metals in the sediment of Taihu Lake[J].Environmental Science,2012,33(12):4291-4299(in Chinese)
• [12]戴秀丽,孙成.太湖沉积物中重金属污染状况及分布特征探讨[J].上海环境科学,2001,20(2):71-74Dai X L,Sun C.The characteristics of heavy metals distribution and pollution in sediment from Lake Taihu[J].Shanghai Environmental Sciences,2001,20(2):71-74(in Chinese)
• [13]余海静,张深,邹国防,等.生物配体模型预测太湖水体中Cu的形态分布和生物有效性[J].环境化学,2014,33(7):1107-1114Yu H J,Zhang S,Zou G F,et al.Predicting copper speciation and bio-availability in Taihu Lake using Biotic Ligand Model(BLM)[J].Environmental Chemistry,2014,33(7):1107-1114(in Chinese)
• [14]United States Environmental Protection Agency(US EPA).Understanding and Accounting for Method Variability in Whole Effluent Toxicity Applications under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Program[R].Washington DC:US EPA,2000
• [15]Fadri G,Bernd N.A probabilistic method for species sensitivity distributions taking into account the inherent uncertainty and variability of effects to estimate environmental risk[J].Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management,2012,9(1):79-86
• [16]Fadri G,Roland W S,Bernd N.Probabilistic material flow modeling for assessing the environmental exposure to compounds:Methodology and an application to engineered nano-Ti O2particles[J].Environmental Modelling&Software,2010,25:320-332
• [17]Hayashi T I,Kashiwagi N.A Bayesian approach to probabilistic ecological risk assessment:Risk comparison of nine toxic substances in Tokyo surface waters[J].Environmental Science and Pollution Research,2011,18:365-375
• [18]United States Environmental Protection Agency(US EPA).Guidelines for Deriving Numerical National Water Quality Criteria for the Protection of Aquatic Organisms and Their Uses[R].(PB 85-227049).Washington DC:US EPA,NTIS,1985
• [19]Klimisch H J,Andreae M,Tillmann U.A systematic approach for evaluating the quality of experimental toxicological and ecotoxicological data[J].Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology,1997,25(1):1-5
• [20]Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development.Report of the OECD Workshop on Extrapolation of Laboratory Aquatic Toxicity Data to the Real Environment[R].Paris:OECD,1992
• [21]苏海磊,吴丰昌,李会仙,等.太湖生物区系研究及与北美五大湖的比较[J].环境科学研究,2011,24(12):1346-1354Su H L,Wu F C,Li H C,et al.Aquatic biota of Taihu Lake and comparison with those of the North American great lakes[J].Research of Environmental Sciences,2011,24(12):1346-1354(in Chinese)
• [22]苏海磊,吴丰昌,李会仙,等.我国水生生物水质基准推导的物种选择[J].环境科学学报,2012,25(5):506-511Su H L,Wu F C,Li H C,et al.Species selection for deriving water quality criteria for protection of aquatic organisms in China[J].Research of Environmental Sciences,2012,25(5):506-511(in Chinese)
• [23]United States Environmental Protection Agency.ECOTOX Database[DB/OL].http://cfpub.epa.gov/ecotox/
• [24]刘伟,吴孝兵,赵娟.重金属Cu2+对锦鲫和日本沼虾的急性毒性研究[J].资源开发与市场,2008,24(10):868-870Liu W,Wu X B,Zhao J.Study on acute toxicity of Cu2+to crucian carp and Japan marsh shrimp[J].Resource Development and Market,2008,24(10):868-870(in Chinese)
• [25]刘晓旭,施蔡雷,曹慧,等.铜和阿特拉津对瓯江彩鲤的联合毒性研究[J].杭州师范大学学报,2010,9(4):263-267Liu X X,Shi C L,Cao H,et al.Joint toxicity of Cu2+and atrazine on C.carpio var.color[J].Journal of Hangzhou Normal University,2010,9(4):263-267(in Chinese)
• [26]杨丽华,方展强,郑文彪.重金属对鲫鱼的生物毒性及安全浓度评价[J].华南师范大学学报,2003(2):101-106Yang L H,Fang Z Q,Zheng W B.Safety assessment and acute toxicity of heavy metals to crucian Carassius auratus[J].Journal of South China Normal University,2003(2):101-106(in Chinese)
• [27]刘大胜,孔强,王大榜,等.金属离子鱼类急性研究及对环境标准修订的启示意义[J].环境科学与管理,2010,35(4):38-42Liu D S,Kong Q,Wang D B,et al.Fish acute toxicity of metal ions and its inspiration for environmental standards revision[J].Environmental Science and Management,2010,35(4):38-42(in Chinese)
• [28]陈万光,屈菊平,邓平平,等.Cu2+,Pb2+对高体鳑鲏幼鱼的急性毒性试验[J].江苏农业科学,2010(4):243-244Chen W G,Qu J P,Deng P P,et al.Acute toxicity test of Cu2+and Pb2+on juvenile Rhodeus ocellatus[J].Journal of Jiangsu Agriculture,2010(4):243-244(in Chinese)
• [29]杨建华,宋维彦.3种重金属离子对中华鳑鲏鱼的急性毒性及安全浓度研究[J].安徽农业科学,2010,38(23):12481-12482,12485Yang J H,Song W Y.Study on acute toxicity and safe concentration of 3 heavy metal ions to Rhodens sinensis gunther[J].Journal of Anhui Agriculture,2010,38(23):12481-12482,12485(in Chinese)
• [30]何志强,郑永华.重金属(铜、锌和汞)对中华倒刺鲃生物毒性效应的研究[D].重庆:西南大学,2008He Z Q,Zheng Y H.Biotoxicity effect studies on heavy metals(copper,zinc and mercury)in Spinibarbus sinensis[D].Chongqing:Southwest University,2008(in Chinese)
• [31]王伟莉,焦聪颖,闫振广,等.水体硬度对铜和镉生物毒性的影响[J].环境工程技术学报,2013,3(3):272-278Wang W L,Jiao C Y,Yan Z G,et al.Effects of water hardness on ecotoxicity of cadmium and copper to aquatic organisms[J].Journal of Environmental Engineering Technology,2012,3(3):272-278(in Chinese)
• [32]程霄玲,郑永华,唐洪玉,等.Cu2+、Zn2+、Cd2+对厚颌鲂幼鱼的联合致毒效应研究[J].淡水渔业,2009,39(2):54-59Chen X L,Zheng Y H,Tang H Y,et al.Study on the joint toxicity of Cu2+,Zn2+,Cd2+to the juvenile of Megalobrama pellegrini[J].Freshwater Fisheries,2009,39(2):54-59(in Chinese)
• [33]叶素兰,余治平.Cu2+、Pb2+、Cd2+、Cr6+对鳙胚胎和仔鱼的急性致毒效应[J].水产科学,2009,28(5):263-267Ye S L,Yu Z P.Acute toxicity of Cu2+,Pb2+,Cd2+and Cr6+to embryos and larvae of bighead carp Aristichthys nobilis[J].Fisheries Science,2009,28(5):263-267(in Chinese)
• [34]张颖.重金属对蛇鮈的急性毒性研究[J].西昌学院学报,2007,21(1):20-23Zhang Y.Acute toxicity of heavy metals to Longnose gudgeon[J].Journal of Xichang College,2007,21(1):20-23(in Chinese)
• [35]朱国霞,季延滨,孙学亮.Cu2+,Fe2+及铜铁合剂对血鹦鹉幼鱼的急性毒性试验[J].中国水产,2013(8):56-58Zhu G X,Ji Y B,Sun X L.Acute toxicity test of Cu2+,Fe2+and copper iron micture on juvenile blood parrotfish[J].Journal of Fishery of China,2013(8):56-58(in Chinese)
• [36]姚志峰,章龙珍,庄平,等.铜对中华鲟幼鱼的急性毒性及对肝脏抗氧化酶活性的影响[J].中国水产科学,2010,17(4):731-738Yao Z F,Zhang L Z,Zhuang P,et al.Effects of antioxidant enzyme in liver and acute toxicity of Cu2+on juvenile Chinese sturgeon[J].Journal of Fishery Sciences of China,2010,17(4):731-738(in Chinese)
• [37]杨帆,邹容.3种重金属对瓦氏黄颡鱼的急性毒性试验[J].水产科学,2008,27(7):368-369Yang F,Zou R.Acute toxicity of three heavy metals to yellow catfish Pelteobagrus vachelli[J].Fisheries Science,2008,27(7):368-369(in Chinese)
• [38]朱旭,陈雷,于俊海,等.Cu2+对泥鳅急性毒性试验[J].辽宁化工,2012,41(9):880-881Zhu X,Chen L,Yu J H,et al.Acute toxicity test of Cu2+for loach[J].Liaoning Chemical Industry,2012,41(9):880-881(in Chinese)
• [39]杨亚琴,贾秀英.Cu2+、Zn2+和Cd2+对蟾蜍蝌蚪的联合毒性[J].应用与环境生物学报,2006,12(3):356-359Yang Y Q,Jia X Y.Joint toxicity of Cu2+、Zn2+and Cd2+to tadpole of Bufo bufo gargarizans[J].Chinese Journal of Applied&Environmental Biology,2006,12(3):356-359(in Chinese)
• [40]王爱民.四种重金属对绿蟾蜍蝌蚪的急性毒性研究[J].新疆大学学报,1990,7(1):60-64Wang A M.Acute toxicity of 4 heavy metals on the tadpoles of Bufo viridis laurenti[J].Journal of Xinjiang University,1990,7(1):60-64(in Chinese)
• [41]石戈,王健鑫,王日昕.Cu2+对中国林蛙蝌蚪生长发育的毒性效应[J].吉林师范大学学报,2007(3):71-73Shi G,Wang J X,Wang R X.Toxic effects of Cu2+on Rana chensinensis tadpole growth and development[J].Journal of Jilin Normal University,2007(3):71-73(in Chinese)
• [42]姚丹,万琳燕,耿宝荣,等.Cu2+对日本林蛙蝌蚪的急性毒性研究[J].福建师范大学学报,2004,20(4):117-120Yao D,Wan L Y,Geng B R,et al.Acute toxicity of Cu2+to Rana japonica tadpoles[J].Journal of Fujian Normal University,2004,20(4):117-120(in Chinese)
• [43]黄帆,郭正元,徐珍,等.霸螨灵与Cu2+对蝌蚪的急性毒性试验研究[J].云南环境科学,2006,25(2):1-3Huang F,Guo Z Y,Xu Z,et al.Study on acute toxicity of Fenpyroximate and copper to tadpole[J].Yunnan Environmental Science,2006,25(2):1-3(in Chinese)
• [44]汪学英,卢祥云,李春梅,等.重金属离子对黑斑蛙胚胎及蝌蚪的毒性影响[J].四川动物,2001,20(2):59-61Wang X Y,Lu X Y,Li C M,et al.Toxicity of heavy metal irons to embryos and larvae of Rana nigromaculata[J].Sichuan Journal of Zoology,2001,20(2):59-61(in Chinese)
• [45]杨再福.铜和汞对蝌蚪联合毒性的影响[J].农业环境保护,2001,20(5):370-371Yang Z F.Joint-toxicity of copper and hydrargyrum on tadpole[J].Agro-environmental Protection,2001,20(5):370-371(in Chinese)
• [46]王志铮,吕敢堂,施建军,等.4种重金属离子对中华鳖(Trionyx sinensis)稚鳖的急性毒性效应[J].海洋与湖沼,2009,40(6):745-752Wang Z Z,Lv G T,Shi J J,et al.Acute toxic effects of four heavy metals on Trionyx sinensis juveniles[J].Oceanologia et Limnologia Sinica,2009,40(6):745-752(in Chinese)
• [47]杞桑,吴棉国,张弦.三种枝角类的实验生物学和急性毒性试验[J].暨南大学学报,1991,12(3):73-78Qi S,Wu J G,Zhang X.The biological characteristics of three cladocerans and acute toxic test[J].Journal of Jinan University,1991,12(3):73-78(in Chinese)
• [48]刘存歧,安通伟,张亚娟,等.Cu2+对日本沼虾的毒性研究[J].安徽农业科学,2008,36(28):12285-12286Liu C Q,An T W,Zhang Y J,et al.Toxicity study of Cu2+on Macrobrachium nipponense[J].Journal of Anhui Agriculture Science,2008,36(28):12285-12286(in Chinese)
• [49]江敏,臧维玲,姚庆祯,等.四种重金属对罗氏沼虾仔虾的毒性作用[J].上海水产大学学报,2002,11(3):203-207Jiang M,Zang W L,Yao Q Z,et al.The toxicity of four heavy metals on Macrobrachium rosenbergii postlarva[J].Journal of Shanghai Fisheries University,2002,11(3):203-207(in Chinese)
• [50]董学兴,吕林兰,王爱民,等.Cu2+和Cd2+对克氏原螯虾幼虾的毒性效应研究[J].水生态学杂志,2010,3(3):90-93Dong X X,Lv L L,Wang A M,et al.Study on the acute toxicity of Cu2+and Cd2+acting on Procambarus clarkia juvenile[J].Journal of Hydroecology,2010,3(3):90-93(in Chinese)
• [51]米静洁,袁慧,王兰.铜、镉、铬、铅对河南华溪蟹的急性毒性作用[J].安徽农业科学,2008,36(17):7273-7274,7321Mi J J,Yuan H,Wang L.Study on the acute toxic effects of and on Sinopotamon henanense[J].Journal of Anhui Agriculture Science,2008,36(17):7273-7274,7321(in Chinese)
• [52]赵含英,杨家新,陆正和,等.Cu2+对萼花臂尾轮虫的毒性影响[J].南京师大学报,2002,25(4):81-85,90Zhao H Y,Yang J X,Lu Z H,et al.The toxic effect of Cu2+on rotifer Brachionus calyciflorus[J].Journal of Nanjing Normal University,2002,25(4):81-85,90(in Chinese)
• [53]潘林.Pb2+和Cu2+对水螅的急性毒性作用以及对SOD活性的影响[J].高师理科学刊,2010,30(2):72-75,85Pan L.Effect of Pb2+and Cu2+on Hydra.sp.acute toxicity and SOD activity[J].Journal of Science of Teachers’College and University,2010,30(2):72-75,85(in Chinese)
• [54]陈德辉,杨剑慧,章宗涉,等.藻类的接触致毒-恢复培养及其对化学物质的安全评价[J].水生生物学报,1999,23(5):455-459Chen D H,Yang J H,Zhang Z S,et al.Algal toxicity test with exposure-recovery and its application to the safety assessmen of chemicals[J].Acta Hydrobiologica Sinica,1999,23(5):455-459(in Chinese)
• [55]刘益浩,王超.斜生栅藻与重金属的相互作用研究[D].南京:河海大学,2007Liu Y H,Wang C.Interactions between Scenedesmus Obliquus and heavy metals[D].Nanjing:Hohai University,2007(in Chinese)
• [56]闫海,潘纲,霍润兰.铜、锌和锰抑制月形藻生长的毒性效应[J].环境科学学报,2001,21(3):328-332Yan H,Pan G,Huo R L.Oxic effects of copper,zinc and manganese on the inhibition of the growth of Closterium lunula[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2001,21(3):328-332(in Chinese)
• [57]潘永全,张云美,韩志刚,等.红剑鱼、孔雀鱼、食蚊鱼亚慢性毒性试验[J].四川动物,2007,26(3):674-678Pan Y Q,Zhang Y M,Han Z G,et al.Subchronic toxicity test for Xiphophorus helleri,Lebistes reticulates and Gambusia affinis[J].Sichuan Journal of Zoology,2007,26(3):674-678(in Chinese)
• [58]United States Environmental Protection Agency(US EPA).Great lakes water quality initiative criteria documents for the protection of aquatic life in ambient water[R].(EPA-820-B-95-004).Washington DC:US EPA,Office of Water,2009
• [59]易秀.铜对生物有机体的毒性及抗性机理[J].农业环境保护,1997,16(4):187-189Yi X.Toxicity of copper on biological organisms and resistance mechanism of biological organisms[J].Agroenvironmental Protection,1997,16(4):187-189(in Chinese)
• [60]孔祥臻,何伟,秦宁,等.重金属对淡水生物生态风险的物种敏感性分布评估[J].中国环境科学,2011,31(9):1555-1562Kong X Z,He W,Qin N,et al.Assessing acute ecological risks of heavy metals to freshwater organisms by species sensitivity distributions[J].China Environmental Science,2011,31(9):1555-1562(in Chinese)
• [61]Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment.Protocol for the derivation of water quality guidelines for the protection of aquatic life[R].Winnipeg:Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment,1999
• [62]Australia and New Zealand Environment and Conservation Council and Agriculture and Resource Management Council of Australia and New Zealand.Australia and New Zealand guidelines for fresh and marine water quality[R].Canberra:ANZECC and ARMCANZ,2000
• [63]United States Environmental Protection Agency(US EPA).National Recommended Water Quality Criteria[R].Washington DC:Office of Water,Office of Science and Technology,2009