再生水处理过程中轮状病毒的变化规律及风险评价Change of Rotavirus in Sewage Treatment Processes and Associated Health Risk Assessment
张德友;何晓青;程莉;谢响明;王东红;王子健;
摘要(Abstract):
为探讨污水处理厂不同处理工艺段对轮状病毒(Rotavirus)的去除效果及再生水回用中轮状病毒对暴露人群的健康风险水平,于2006年11月至2007年10月连续对北京市某污水厂各工艺段出水的轮状病毒进行了分析,并应用Beta-Possion模型对回用再生水中轮状病毒对暴露人群的健康风险水平进行了评价.结果表明,36个实测水样中,轮状病毒检测结果为阳性的样品13个,占总样品数的36.1%.阳性样品主要分布在2006年11月、12月和2007年1月、2月、4月、8月和10月所采集的样品中,各月份阳性样品所占比例分别依次为100%、100%、100%、33.3%、66.7%、33.3%和100%.二级处理工艺对轮状病毒的去除率为2.68-lg,二级处理出水经过混凝沉淀和砂滤两种深度处理后得到再生水,深度处理工艺平均去除率为3.01-lg.二沉出水回用对不同职业暴露人群的年均感染概率风险值范围为0.35×10-2~10.36×10-2,再生水回用不同职业暴露人群年平均感染风险概率值范围为0.23×10-2~6.82×10-2,二沉出水、再生水回用导致的道路喷洒职业工人轮状病毒暴露感染风险值最大,分别达到了39.65×10-2和36.82×10-2,存在着一定的健康风险.
关键词(KeyWords): 实时荧光定量PCR;轮状病毒;污水处理;风险评价
基金项目(Foundation): 国家“863”重点项目(No.2008AA062501);; 国家水体污染控制与治理科技重大专项(No.2009ZX07527-005);; 国家科技支撑项目(No.2006BAD01B06-03;No.2006BAJ08B02)
作者(Author): 张德友;何晓青;程莉;谢响明;王东红;王子健;
Email:
DOI:
参考文献(References):
- Baggi F,Demarta A,Peduzzi R.2001.Persistence of viralpathogens and bacteriophages during sewage treatment:lack ofcorrelation with indicator bacteria[J].Research in Microbiology,152(8):743-751
- Baggi F,Peduzzi R.2000.Genotyping of rotaviruses inenvironmental water and stool samples in southern Switzerland bynucleotide sequence analysis of189base pairs at the5’end ofthe VP7gene[J].Journal of Clinical Microbiology,38(10):3681-3685
- Brenner A,Shandalov S,Messalem R,Yakirevich A,Oron G,Rebhun M.2000.A wastewater reclamation for agricultural reusein Israel:Trends and experimental results[J].Warer,Air,andSoil Pollution,123(1-4):167-182
- Cheng L,He X Q,Li W,Ma M,Wang Z J,Xie X M.2007.Detection of rotaviruses in urban water samples from a city inNorth China[J].Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology,2(2):202-207(in Chinese)
- Chu J Y,Chen J N,Wang C,Fu P.2004.Wastewater reusepotential analysis:implications for China’s water resourcesmanagement[J].Water Research,38(11):2746-2756
- Haas C N,Rose J B,Gerba C,Regli S.1993.Risk assessmentof virus in drinking water[J].Risk Analysis,13(5):545-552
- He X H,Ma S H,Li A D.2006.Concentration limitations ofpathogenic microorganisms in reclaimed water[J].EnvironmentalScience,27(7):1403-1405(in Chinese)
- Lodder W J,De Roda Husman A M.2005.Presence ofnoroviruses and other enteric viruses in sewage and surfacewaters in the Netherlands[J].Applied and EnvironmentalMicrobiology,71(3):1453-1461
- Mara D D,Sleigh P A,Blumenthal U J,Carr R M.2007.Health risks in wastewater irrigation:comparing estimates fromquantitative microbial risk analyses and epidemiological studies[J].Journal of Water and Health,5(1):39-50
- Melnick J L,Gerba C P,Berg G.1980.The ecology ofenteroviruses in natural waters[J].Critical Reviews in EnvironmentalScience and Technology,10(1):65-93
- Ministry of Health of the People’s Republic of China,StandardizationAdministration of the People’s Republic of China.2007.GB5749-2006Standards for Drinking Water Quality[S].Beijing:Standards Press of China(in Chinese)
- Myrmel M,Berg E M,Grinde B,Rimstad E.2006.Entericviruses in inlet and outlet samples from sewage treatment plants[J].Journal of Water and Health,4(2):197-209
- Pang X L,Lee B,Boroumand N,Leblanc B,Preiksaitis J K,Yu Ip C C.2004.Increased detection of rotavirus using a realtime reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction(RT-PCR)assay in stool specimens from children with diarrhea[J].Journalof Medical Virology,72(3):496-501
- Parashar U D,Gibson C J,Bresee J S,Glass R I.2006.Rotavirus and severe childhood diarrhea[J].Emerging InfectiousDiseases,12(2):304-306
- Pusch D,Oh D Y,Wolf S,Dumke R,Schroter-Bobsin U,H觟hne M,R觟ske I,Schreier E.2005.Detection of entericviruses and bacterial indicators in German environmental waters[J].Archives of Virology,150(5):929-947
- Rutjes S A,Lodder W J,Van Leeuwen A D,De Roda HusmanA M.2009.Detection of infectious rotavirus in naturallycontaminated source waters for drinking water production[J].Journal of Applied Microbiology,107(1):97-105
- Rzezutka A,Cook N.2004.Survival of human enteric viruses inthe environment and food[J].FEMS Microbiology Reviews,28(4):441-453
- Schijven J F,De Bruin H A M,Hassanizadeh S M,De RodaHusman A M.2003.Bacteriophages and clostridium spores asindicator organisms for removal of pathogens by passage throughsaturated dune sand[J].Water Research,37(9):2186-2194
- Wyn-Jones A P,Sellwood J.2001.Enteric viruses in theaquatic environment[J].Journal of Applied Microbiology,91(6):945-962
- Zhang J,Li B Q,Li J X,Gao J.2004.Research oncountermeasures of urban wastewater treatment and utilizaton inChina[J].Journal of Hunan University of Science&Technology(Natural Science Edition),6(2):80-83(in Chinese)
- 程莉,何晓青,李伟,马梅,王子健,谢响明.2007.北方某市城区水环境中轮状病毒的初步检测[J].生态毒理学报,2(2):202-207
- 何晓青,李伟,程莉,马梅,王子健.2006.北京城区水环境中轮状病毒的初步研究[A].//中国生态学会微生物生态委员会2006年年会论文集[C].北京
- 何星海,马世豪,李安定.2006.再生水利用的病原微生物浓度限探讨[J].环境科学,27(7):1403-1405
- 王蓓,方肇寅,高倩.2005.中国轮状病毒腹泻的经济负担浅析[C].第二届国际轮状病毒疫苗研讨会,北京
- 张杰,李碧清,李继祥,高洁.2004.我国城市污水处理与利用对策研究[J].湖南科技大学学报(自然科学版),6(2):80-83
- 中华人民共和国卫生部,国家标准化管理委员会.2007.GB5749-2006生活饮用水卫生标准[S].北京:中国标准出版社