王铜;孙傅;曾思育;何苗;

• 1:清华大学环境学院

摘要(Abstract)：

随着北京市再生水补给河湖规模扩大,污水处理厂出水中雌激素活性物质引起的受纳水体生态风险日益受到关注。以雌二醇为例,利用物种敏感度分布(species sensitivity distribution,SSD)模型和联合概率曲线(joint probability curve,JPC)方法开展北京市污水处理厂出水的概率生态风险评价研究。通过文献调研整理了北京市约430个物种,利用美国环境保护署ECOTOX数据库获取了其中7个物种的雌二醇毒性数据,构建了正态分布、对数正态分布、Logistic分布、对数Logistic分布、Weibull分布、Burr III型分布和Gumbel分布等7个SSD模型,评价了北京市污水处理厂二沉池出水以及"混凝-沉淀-过滤-臭氧"、"超滤-臭氧"和"超滤-活性炭-臭氧"3种深度处理工艺组合出水的生态风险。结果表明,利用北京市7个物种雌二醇毒性数据构建的SSD模型具有合理性,SSD模型选择对生态风险评价结果的影响较大,对数正态分布、对数Logistic分布、Weibull分布和Burr III型均是可接受的SSD模型,其中拟合效果最佳的Burr III型分布模型给出了最保守的风险估计。Burr III型分布模型的模拟结果显示,北京市污水处理厂二沉池出水以及3种深度处理工艺组合出水的总体风险期望值分别为0.070、0.040、0.036和0.026,该结果可以为北京市未来水生态保护目标的设定以及污水处理工艺的升级改造提供决策参考。

关键词(KeyWords)： 雌二醇;本地物种;生态风险;污水处理厂;物种敏感度曲线;联合概率曲线

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家水体污染控制与治理科技重大专项(2009ZX07318-001-02)

作者(Author): 王铜;孙傅;曾思育;何苗;

Email:

DOI:

参考文献(References)：

• [1]Peng X Z,Yu Y Y,Tang C M,et al.Occurrence of steroid estrogens,endocrine-disrupting phenols,and acid pharmaceutical residues in urban riverine water of the Pearl River Delta,South China[J].Science of the Total Environment,2008,397(1-3):158-166
• [2]Sun Q F,Deng S B,Huang J,et al.Contributors to estrogenic activity in wastewater from a large wastewater treatment plant in Beijing,China[J].Environmental Toxicology and Pharmacology,2008,25(1):20-26
• [3]Zhao J L,Ying G G,Wang L,et al.Determination of phenolic endocrine disrupting chemicals and acidic pharmaceuticals in surface water of the Pearl Rivers in South China by gas chromatography-negative chemical ionization-mass spectrometry[J].Science of the Total Environment,2009,407(2):962-974
• [4]Sui Q,Huang J,Deng S B,et al.Occurrence and removal of pharmaceuticals,caffeine and DEET in wastewater treatment plants of Beijing,China[J].Water Research,2010,44(2):417-426
• [5]Sui Q,Huang J,Deng S B,et al.Seasonal variation in the occurrence and removal of pharmaceuticals and personal care products in different biological wastewater treatment processes[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2011,45(8):3341-3348
• [6]Chang H,Wan Y,Wu S M,et al.Occurrence of androgens and progestogens in wastewater treatment plants and receiving river waters:Comparison to estrogens[J].Water Research,2011,45(2):732-740
• [7]孙艳,黄璜,胡洪营,等.污水处理厂出水中雌激素活性物质浓度与生态风险水平[J].环境科学研究,2010,23(12):1488-1493Sun Y,Huang H,Hu H Y,et al.Concentration and ecological risk level of estrogenic endocrine-disrupting chemicals in the effluents from wastewater treatment plants[J].Research of Environmental Sciences,2010,23(12):1488-1493(in Chinese)
• [8]Wang Y Q,Hu W,Cao Z H,et al.Occurrence of endocrine-disrupting compounds in reclaimed water from Tianjin,China[J].Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry,2005,383(5):857-863
• [9]Fan Z L,Wu S M,Chang H,et al.Behaviors of glucocorticoids,androgens and progestogens in a municipal sewage treatment plant:Comparison to estrogens[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2011,45(7):2725-2733
• [10]Li N,Ma M,Rao K F,et al.In vitro thyroid disrupting effects of organic extracts from WWTPs in Beijing[J].Journal of Environmental Sciences,2011,23(4):671-675
• [11]Rao K F,Li N,Ma M,et al.In vitro agonistic and antagonistic endocrine disrupting effects of organic extracts from waste water of different treatment processes[J].Frontiers of Environmental Science&Engineering,2014,8(1):69-78
• [12]Desbrow C,Routledge E J,Brighty G C,et al.Identification of estrogenic chemicals in STW effluent.1.Chemical fractionation and in vitro biological screening[J].Environmental Science&Technology,1998,32(11):1549-1558
• [13]Routledge E J,Sheahan D,Desbrow C,et al.Identification of estrogenic chemicals in STW effluent.2.In vivo responses in trout and roach[J].Environmental Science&Technology,1998,32(11):1559-1565
• [14]Welshons W V,Thayer K A,Judy B M,et al.Large effects from small exposures.I.Mechanisms for endocrine-disrupting chemicals with estrogenic activity[J].Environmental Health Perspectives,2003,111(8):994-1006
• [15]Vom Saal F S,Hughes C.An extensive new literature concerning low-dose effects of bisphenol A shows the need for a new risk assessment[J].Environmental Health Perspectives,2005,113(8):926-933
• [16]Zha J M,Wang Z J.Assessing technological feasibility for wastewater reclamation based on early life stage toxicity of Japanese medaka(Oryzias latipes)[J].Agriculture,Ecosystems&Environment,2005,107(2-3):187-198
• [17]Zha J M,Wang Z J.Acute and early life stage toxicity of industrial effluent on Japanese medaka(Oryziaslatipes)[J].Science of the Total Environment,2006,357(1-3):112-119
• [18]Zha J M,Sun L W,Zhou Y Q,et al.Assessment of17α-ethinylestradiol effects and underlying mechanisms in a continuous,multigeneration exposure of the Chinese rare minnow(Gobiocypris rarus)[J].Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology,2008,226(3):298-308
• [19]Jukosky J A,Watzin M C,Leiter J C.The effects of environmentally relevant mixtures of estrogens on Japanese medaka(Oryzias latipes)reproduction[J].Aquatic Toxicology,2008,86(2):323-331
• [20]Waiser M J,Humphries D,Tumber V,et al.Effluentdominated streams.Part 2:Presence and possible effects of pharmaceuticals and personal care products in Wascana Creek,Saskatchewan,Canada[J].Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry,2011,30(2):508-519
• [21]雷炳莉,黄圣彪,王子健.生态风险评价理论和方法[J].化学进展,2009,21(2/3):350-358Lei B L,Huang S B,Wang Z J.Theories and methods of ecological risk assessment[J].Progress in Chemistry,2009,21(2/3):350-358(in Chinese)
• [22]郭广慧,吴丰昌,何宏平,等.太湖梅梁湾、贡湖湾和胥口湾水体PAHs的生态风险评价[J].环境科学学报,2011,31(12):2804-2813Guo G H,Wu F C,He H P,et al.Ecological risk assessment of PAHs in the Meiliang Bay,Gonghu Bay,and Xukou Bay of Taihu Lake[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,2011,31(12):2804-2813(in Chinese)
• [23]Aldenberg T,Jaworska J S,Traas T P.Normal species sensitivity distributions and probabilistic ecological risk assessment[M]//Species Sensitivity Distributions in Ecotoxicology.Boca Raton,USA:Lewis Publishers,2002:49-102
• [24]金小伟,王业耀,王子健.淡水水生态基准方法学研究:数据筛选与模型计算[J].生态毒理学报,2014,9(1):1-13Jin X W,Wang Y Y,Wang Z J.Methodologies for deriving aquatic life criteria(ALC):Data screening and model calculation[J].Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology,2014,9(1):1-13(in Chinese)
• [25]ANZECC(Australian and New Zealand Environment and Conservation Council),ARMCANZ(Agriculture and Resource Management Council of Australia and New Zealand).Australian and New Zealand guidelines for fresh and marine water quality.Volume 2[R].Canberra:ANZECC and ARMCANZ,2000
• [26]Wheeler J R,Grist E P M,Leung K M Y,et al.Species sensitivity distributions:Data and model choice[J].Marine Pollution Bulletin,2002,45(1):192-202
• [27]CCME(Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment).A protocol for the derivation of water quality guidelines for the protection of aquatic life 2007[R].Winnipeg:CCME,2007
• [28]北京市发展和改革委员会.近年来北京市用水量变化情况[EB/OL].(2009-12-16)[2014-04-22].http://www.bjpc.gov.cn/zt/09shui/xgqk/200912/t510940.htm
• [29]Falconer I R,Chapman H F,Moore M R,et al.Endocrine-disrupting compounds:A review of their challenge to sustainable and safe water supply and water reuse[J].Environmental Toxicology,2006,21(2):181-191
• [30]曹仲宏,马永民,胡伟,等.再生水中内分泌干扰物的初步研究[J].环境与健康杂志,2005,22(3):171-173Cao Z H,Ma Y M,Hu W,et al.Endocrine disrupting compounds in reclaimed water produced by a certain water plant:Some preliminary results[J].Journal of Environment and Health,2005,22(3):171-173(in Chinese)
• [31]黄深.城市污水厂二级处理出水臭氧深度处理研究[D].北京:清华大学,2008Huang S.Advanced treatment of secondary effluent by ozonation[D].Beijing:Tsinghua University,2008(in Chinese)
• [32]Solomon K,Giesy J,Jones P.Probabilistic risk assessment of agrochemicals in the environment[J].Crop Protection,2000,19(8):649-655
• [33]Wang Z,Wang Y,Ma X D,et al.Probabilistic ecological risk assessment of typical PAHs in coastal water of Bohai Sea[J].Polycyclic Aromatic Compounds,2013,33(4):367-379
• [34]Jin X W,Wang Y Y,Jin W,et al.Ecological risk of nonylphenol in China surface waters based on reproductive fitness[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2014,48(2):1256-1262
• [35]王宏伟,昌艳萍,张磊,等.拒马河原生动物和底栖动物初步调查及水质分析[J].动物学杂志,2006,41(4):77-82Wang H W,Chang Y P,Zhang L,et al.Primary survey on protozoa and benthos and assessment of water quality in Juma River[J].Chinese Journal of Zoology,2006,41(4):77-82(in Chinese)
• [36]任淑智.北京小型湖泊底栖无脊椎动物群落结构特征与营养状况的研究[J].应用生态学报,1991,2(3):221-225Ren S Z.Community structure of macroinvertebrates and trophic level of several small lakes in Beijing city[J].Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,1991,2(3):221-225(in Chinese)
• [37]许木启.京密运河-北京排污河浮游动物群落变化与水质关系的研究[J].环境科学学报,1993,13(3):347-354Xu M Q.Relationship between change in zooplankton community and water quality of Jingmi Canal and Beijing sewage stream[J].Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,1993,13(3):347-354(in Chinese)
• [38]王鸿媛,北京鱼类和两栖.爬行动物志[M].北京:北京出版社,1994
• [39]杨文波,李继龙,李绪兴,等.拒马河北京段鱼类组成及其多样性[J].上海水产大学学报,2008,17(2):175-181Yang W B,Li J L,Li X X,et al.Fish composition and species biodiversity of the Beijing section of Juma River[J].Journal of Shanghai Fisheries University,2008,17(2):175-181(in Chinese)
• [40]卫新锋,赵彦伟,彭可扬,等.北京市五景观湖泊浮游藻类评价及聚类分析[J].水土保持研究,2009,16(2):212-215Wei X F,Zhao Y W,Peng K Y,et al.Phytoplankton evaluation and cluster analysis of 5 landscape-lakes in Beijing[J].Research of Soil and Water Conservation,2009,16(2):212-215(in Chinese)
• [41]李竹,杨定,李枢强.北京地区常见昆虫和其他无脊椎动物[M].北京:北京科学技术出版社,2011
• [42]李永刚.密云水库浮游生物底栖动物群落结构及生物多样性研究[D].北京:中国农业科学院研究生院,2012Li Y G.Studies of the community structure and biodiversity of plankton and zoobenthos in Miyun Reservoir[D].Beijing:Graduate School of Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences,2012(in Chinese)
• [43]高彩凤.北运河水系水生态调查及水质评价[D].河南:河南师范大学,2012Gao C F.Investigation of aquatic ecosystem and water quality evaluation in Beiyunhe River[D].Henan:Henan Normal University,2012(in Chinese)
• [44]张春光,赵亚辉.北京及其邻近地区的鱼类:物种多样性、资源评价和原色图谱[M].北京:科学出版社,2013Zhang C G,Zhao Y H.Fishes in Beijing and adjacent areas,China[M].Beijing:Science Press,2013(in Chinese)
• [45]Deborde M,Rabouan S,Duguet J P,et al.Kinetics of aqueous ozone-induced oxidation of some endocrine disruptors[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2005,39(16):6086-6092
• [46]Westerhoff P,Yoon Y,Snyder S A,et al.Fate of endocrine-disruptor,pharmaceutical,and personal care product chemicals during simulated drinking water treatment processes[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2005,39(17):6649-6663
• [47]Huber M M,Gobel A,Joss A,et al.Oxidation of pharmaceuticals during ozonation of municipal wastewater effluents:A pilot study[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2005,39(11):4290-4299
• [48]王淑娟.典型水处理过程中有毒有机物质的污染与去除[D].北京:北京林业大学,2006Wang S J.Study on the pollution and removal of toxic organic pollutants in typical water treatment process[D].Beijing:Beijing Forestry University,2006(in Chinese)
• [49]Hashimoto T,Takahashi K,Murakami T.Characteristics of estrogen decomposition by ozonation[J].Water Science&Technology,2006,54(10):87-93
• [50]Snyder S A,Adham S,Redding A M,et al.Role of membranes and activated carbon in the removal of endocrine disruptors and pharmaceuticals[J].Desalination,2007,202(1):156-181
• [51]周益奇.北京市不同水体中内分泌干扰物质的来源和归属[D].北京:中国科学院研究生院,2008Zhou Y Q.Source and fate of endocrine disrupting compounds in different water body in Beijing,China[D].Beijing:Graduate School of the Chinese Academy of Sciences,2008(in Chinese)
• [52]Broseus R,Vincent S,Aboulfadl K,et al.Ozone oxidation of pharmaceuticals,endocrine disruptors and pesticides during drinking water treatment[J].Water Re-search,2009,43(18):4707-4717
• [53]Yoon Y,Westerhoff P,Snyder S A,et al.HPLC-fluorescence detection and adsorption of bisphenol A,17β-estradiol,and 17α-ethynyl estradiol on powdered activated carbon[J].Water Research,2003,37(14):3530-3537
• [54]Yoon Y,Westerhoff P,Snyder S A,et al.Removal of endocrine disrupting compounds and pharmaceuticals by nanofiltration and ultrafiltration membranes[J].Desalination,2007,202(1):16-23
• [55]Zhou H D,Huang X,Wang X L,et al.Behaviour of selected endocrine-disrupting chemicals in three sewage treatment plants of Beijing,China[J].Environmental Monitoring and Assessment,2010,161(1-4):107-121
• [56]Zhou Y Q,Zha J M,Wang Z J.Occurrence and fate of steroid estrogens in the largest wastewater treatment plant in Beijing,China[J].Environmental Monitoring and Assessment,2012,184(11):6799-6813
• [57]Caldwell D J,Mastrocco F,Hutchinson T H,et al.Derivation of an aquatic predicted no-effect concentration for the synthetic hormone,17α-ethinyl estradiol[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2008,42(19):7046-7054
• [58]Caldwell D J,Mastrocco F,Anderson P D,et al.Predicted-no-effect concentration for the steroid estrogens estrone,17β-estradiol,estriol,and 17α-ethinylestradiol[J].Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry,2012,31(6):1396-1406
• [59]Young W F,Whitehouse P,Johnson I,et al.Proposed predicted-no-effect-concentrations(PNECs)for natural and synthetic steroid oestrogens in surface waters[R].Bristol:Environmental Agency R&D Dissemination Centre,2004
• [60]Kramer V J,Miles-Richardson S,Pierens S L,et al.Reproductive impairment and induction of alkaline-labile phosphate,a biomarker of estrogen exposure,in fathead minnows(Pimephales promelas)exposed to waterborne17β-estradiol[J].Aquatic Toxicology,1998,40(4):335-360